Click here to Book Your Stay
The first time I visited Put-in-Bay, I wasn’t exactly sure what to expect. I’d heard people call it “Key West of the North” and a “party island,” but I quickly realized it’s so much more than that. It’s a mix of lake views, history, music, and the kind of small-town charm that instantly slows you down.
If it’s your first time heading to the island, here are the 10 things I did on my trip that made it unforgettable — and that I’d recommend to anyone visiting for the first time.
1. I Started at Perry’s Victory & International Peace Memorial
As soon as I got off the ferry, that towering monument caught my eye. So naturally, I made it my first stop. I took the elevator to the top, and wow — the view stretched across Lake Erie and into Canada. It’s one of those “you’ve gotta see it yourself” moments.
Lesson learned: Don’t skip this, especially if it’s a clear day. It’s a perfect intro to the island.
2. I Relaxed at South Bass Island State Park
Later that afternoon, I needed a breather, and this park was the perfect spot. Quiet, scenic, and less crowded than the downtown strip. I watched boats roll by, dipped my feet in the water, and just… unplugged.
Pro tip: It’s the best place to catch a sunset. Bring a blanket or a couple of drinks and stay a while.
3. I Toured Heineman’s Winery and Walked Through a Giant Geode
I love wine, but I wasn’t expecting a geode the size of a room under the winery! Heineman’s offered a tour of both the Crystal Cave and the winery, and I got to sample their sweet island wine afterward.
What I sipped: Their Pink Catawba was light, fruity, and perfect for the summer heat.
4. I Rented a Golf Cart and Explored Freely
I’ll be honest — riding around Put-in-Bay in a golf cart was half the fun. There’s something about zipping around with the wind in your face and no real plan. I cruised past vineyards, cottages, and little side roads I’d have missed by foot.
Heads up: Reserve your cart early if you’re visiting on a weekend. They go fast.
Click here to Book Your Stay
5. I Found Peace in the Butterfly House
I didn’t think this would be a highlight, but it totally was. Imagine walking into a quiet greenhouse filled with butterflies flying around and landing on your shoulders. It was calm, colorful, and strangely meditative.
Great for kids and adults alike. Also a break from the music and buzz downtown.
6. I Ate Lobster Bisque at the Boardwalk (In a Bread Bowl!)
I still think about this meal. The Lobster Bisque at the Boardwalk is legendary, and now I understand why. Creamy, rich, and served in a bread bowl, with the marina in the background. That meal was my afternoon.
Bonus: Grab a table on the top deck for the best harbor views.
7. I Visited the Lake Erie Islands Historical Society
On my second morning, I wanted to get a better feel for the island beyond the bars. This little museum, just steps from Perry’s Monument, gave me a crash course in the island’s history — from naval battles to tourism and quirky traditions.
Tip: It’s air-conditioned and a great quiet stop during peak hours.
8. I Let Loose on Delaware Avenue
Okay, yes — the nightlife is very real in Put-in-Bay. That evening, I wandered into Mr. Ed’s, caught a live band, and found myself dancing with strangers who felt like friends by the end of the night. The whole strip comes alive after dark.
My take: It’s rowdy in the best way. Just pace yourself — and leave your cart parked!
9. I Watched the Sunset from the Park Hotel Porch
I randomly ended up sitting on the rocking chairs out front of the old Park Hotel with a to-go drink and some live acoustic music playing nearby. The sun was setting behind the trees, and I remember thinking, This is what summer is supposed to feel like.
It’s free, simple, and unexpectedly magical.
10. I Took the Ferry Back Smiling, Tired, and Already Planning My Return
The boat ride back always hits differently. My camera was full, my legs were sore, and I had this goofy smile from everything I’d packed into two days. That’s when I realized — Put-in-Bay gets in your bones a little.
You don’t just visit. You remember.
Final Thought from a First-Timer
If you’re heading to Put-in-Bay for the first time, come open-minded. It’s part quirky, part relaxing, part wild — and totally unforgettable. Whether you’re bar-hopping, cave-exploring, or just watching the boats go by, there’s a rhythm to the island that pulls you in.
And trust me, once you go… you’ll want to come back.